A Blind Whiskey Tasting: Four Roses Small Batch Select vs. Single Barrel

Four Roses Small Batch Select vs. Single Barrel

A Blind Whiskey Tasting: Four Roses Small Batch Select vs. Single Barrel


In this blind whiskey tasting, we take a look at two offerings from Four Roses Distillery: the Small Batch Select and the Single Barrel. Completely unaware of which glass holds which whiskey, we set out to discover which one impresses us more in terms of aroma, flavor, and overall experience.

Blind Tasting Process

Blind tastings are all about honesty and removing bias. With no labels to influence our opinions, we get a genuine experience with each pour. We explore the nose, palate, and finish of both whiskeys, scoring them based on our real-world perspective as whiskey enthusiasts.

Glass One: Four Roses Small Batch Select


Glass one presents a classic bourbon nose with delightful notes of caramel, apple, vanilla, and oak. The balanced and rounded profile is inviting, with no overpowering ethanol scent.


The taste of this pour is well-rounded, with a fruit-forward profile and a touch of rye spice. The fruity sweetness, followed by the gentle spice, creates a harmonious experience. While not an easy sipper, it remains highly enjoyable.

Overall Experience

Glass one receives high praise for its rich flavors, decent oiliness, and lingering finish of oak and barrel spice. The price of $60 and widespread availability make it a compelling option for whiskey enthusiasts.

Glass Two: Four Roses Single Barrel


Glass two differs from the first, with an earthier aroma and a subtle sweetness that is somewhat muted compared to glass one.


While glass two is still enjoyable, it lacks the boldness and complexity of glass one. It offers a simple sweetness with faint hints of cherry cola.

Overall Experience

Four Roses Single Barrel is easy-sipping with its sweetness and lack of overpowering spice. It may not impress on the same level as Small Batch Select, but it still offers a pleasant experience for those seeking a straightforward pour.

Final Scores and Recommendations

After tallying the scores, Glass One (Four Roses Small Batch Select) earned a solid 7 out of 10, excelling in flavor and overall experience. It’s well worth its $60 price tag.

On the other hand, Glass Two (Four Roses Single Barrel) scored 4.5 out of 10. Although not outstanding, it remains a good option for those looking for an easy-sipping, sweet bourbon at $50.


In conclusion, both whiskeys have their merits and cater to different preferences. Four Roses Small Batch Select appeals to those seeking a rich and flavorful pour with an extra kick of spice. Meanwhile, Four Roses Single Barrel is ideal for those who prefer a simpler, sweeter, and more accessible drinking experience.

Whether you opt for the complexity of Small Batch Select or the straightforward sweetness of Single Barrel, both of these offerings from Four Roses Distillery are enjoyable and worth considering for your whiskey collection. Remember, taste preferences are subjective, so go ahead and explore these bourbons to find the one that best suits your palate. Happy tasting!

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

  1. What is a blind whiskey tasting? Blind whiskey tasting involves tasting different whiskeys without knowing which one is which, eliminating any bias and allowing for a more objective evaluation.
  2. How are the whiskeys scored during the blind tasting? The whiskeys are scored based on their aroma, flavor, and overall experience, with each aspect given a rating to determine their quality.
  3. Is Four Roses Small Batch Select a good option for whiskey enthusiasts? Yes, Four Roses Small Batch Select is highly praised for its rich flavors and lingering finish, making it a compelling choice for whiskey enthusiasts.
  4. What sets Four Roses Single Barrel apart from Small Batch Select? Four Roses Single Barrel offers a simpler and sweeter taste compared to the more complex and spicier profile of Small Batch Select.
  5. Which whiskey is more budget-friendly? Four Roses Single Barrel is priced at $50, making it a more budget-friendly option compared to Small Batch Select, which is priced at $60.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top